academic life

The Open-Door Fallacy

The Open-Door Fallacy

An open door alone does not an ally make. To many in academia who are in distress and who feel voiceless and vulnerable, knocking on another, especially senior, person’s door can be an immense psychological barrier to overcome. After perhaps a lifetime’s worth of discrimination, the path leading to such a door is seldom paved, let alone clear of obstacles. Believing that someone behind it may be an ally stems from a combination of individual experiences that are hard, if not impossible, to anticipate.

Read More

Herring out of Brine: Indefensible

Herring out of Brine: Indefensible

The PhD defense or viva voce examination is the Humanities’ ultimate rite of passage. In part, a court of your own, soon-to-be peers; in part, a speech act conferring and in some less lucky cases denying the status of a Philosophiae Doctor. Despite its arcane name, the variety of graduation formats and procedures is surprisingly broad, and it tells arguably more about the granting institution and its surrounding culture than the discipline, department or quality of research being evaluated.

Read More